Site mobile navigation

  • Home
  • About
    • Executive Board
    • Staff
  • Dartmouth
  • Markets
  • Consumer
  • International
  • Technology
  • Government
  • Contact
Skip to content
Menu

Top navigation

  • About
  • Contact Us
  • Login

Dartmouth Business Journal

Covering Business at Dartmouth and Beyond

Site navigation

  • Home
  • About
    • Executive Board
    • Staff
  • Dartmouth
  • Markets
  • Consumer
  • International
  • Technology
  • Government
  • Contact
  • Home
  • Markets
  • Selecting an Investment Manager
Markets

Selecting an Investment Manager

1086
By Sanjit Deepalam '20November 12, 2018November 12, 2018

The financial world’s focus on investment managers is intense. Everyone involved in finance, from hosts on CNBC, to everyday investors looking for funds and fund managers to learn from and copy, is extremely interested in successful firms and what makes them successful. Furthermore, institutions, endowments, and regular investors are interested in who the best investors are because they want to find the best management for their own money. Although it’s important to judge investment managers, most go about it the wrong way. When judging investment managers, people ought to place much greater emphasis on the firm’s long-term record, the quality and reasoning behind investments decisions and the organizational culture and structure.

One of the most prominent investors today is Bill Ackman, the hedge fund manager behind Pershing Square Capital Management, a fund with a history of shorting stocks and active involvement in company management. For a number of years, Bill Ackman was considered a hedge fund “rock star.” As Investopedia details, Pershing Square made very public, successful bets on companies like Municipal Bond Insurance Association. The fund also helped turn around General Growth Properties, resulting in a $1.6 billion profit on a $60 million investment. As a result, Pershing Square increased 40% in 2014, compared to 9.6 percent for the S&P 500.

However, this success was short-lived. Pershing Square took a $1 billion short position in Herbalife, a nutrition company that it believed to be a pyramid scheme. It also took a 9 percent stake in a Valeant Pharmaceuticals. Both investments performed poorly, and Pershing Square was down 21 percent in 2015 and 14 percent in 2016. As a result, Ackman and Pershing Square went from being the darlings of Wall Street to the subjects of scrutiny. Segments on CNBC questioned whether Ackman had lost his touch, and investors were reportedly pulling their money out of Pershing Square, with the fund’s assets under management decreasing from about $20 billion to around $8 billion.

The remarkable change in opinion regarding Ackman and the firm exemplifies the flaws in a myopic investment strategy that gives much greater weight to the last few years of Pershing Square’s performance. When decision making becomes focused on the short-term, long-term results falter. When investors are deciding whether to invest in funds like Pershing Square, they should strongly consider the fund’s long-term track record, rather than its short-term fluctuations.

Another investor, David Einhorn, offers some insight into how to judge investment managers. Einhorn, a value investor like Bill Ackman with a similar level of Wall Street credibility to that of Einhorn, runs a successful fund called Greenlight Capital. Over the past few years, Greenlight has lost money due to some of its shorts, particularly in its short positions in Tesla and Amazon. These stocks soared as Einhorn bet against them and Greenlight suffered tremendously. Greenlight, like Pershing Square, has had a few years of turbulence but a great long-term record. However, this serves as another demonstration of why it’s important for evaluators of investment managers to consider investment theses along with actual performance.

Einhorn’s arguments against Amazon and Tesla are built on the idea that these companies’ stock prices are fueled by growth expectations, marketing, and celebrity CEO’s, rather than by fundamentals. This is a good argument, but it can also be contested. Regardless of whether Greenlight’s performance over the short-term is up to standard, evaluators of investment managers should look into the theses behind the larger positions held by various managers. If their theses seem poorly supported, careless, or based more on trends than contrarianism, they should look to other investment managers, regardless of that firm’s record.

The most important consideration when evaluating an investment manager’s merit is culture. Culture is a concept that’s often overused with respect to business, but it is arguably more important for investment funds than almost any other corporation. Investment funds are businesses that aim to deliver great returns, relative to risk, for investors. This is their primary goal and also their product. However, unlike many other businesses, investment funds do not have intellectual property, patents, brand names, and past products on which their business can rely for profits and performance. For these types of businesses to differentiate themselves from competitors, and perform better, having a successful company culture is critical.

An excellent example of superior workplace culture in investment management is seen in the firm Ruane, Cunniff & Goldfarb. The fund has a successful and illustrious history, as seen by its ability to deliver market-beating returns to its investors since its establishment in 1969. However, like all companies, Ruane, Cunniff & Goldfarb has experienced some difficulty. In 2016, the company lost a significant amount of money on an investment it made in Valeant Pharmaceutical, a company that Bill Ackman also invested in. Ruane, Cunniff & Goldfarb was particularly hurt by this investment because, at one point, Valeant Pharmaceutical made up more than one-third of Sequoia Fund, Ruane, Cunniff & Goldfarb’s flagship fund.

The losses due to the Valeant position were large, but it was an opportunity for the company to test its culture. Ruane, Cunniff & Goldfarb’s response to this moment of difficulty was exceptional. Instead of attributing the performance to misfortune or a single bad thesis, the company changed the way it made final investing decisions, going from a more centralized decision-making process to a five-person investment committee that requires almost unanimous support for an investment to be added into the portfolio. At the same time, the firm refrained from over compensating, maintaining its belief in both its investment philosophy and its other holdings. Since then, the firm has done well and recovered. And, the self-reflection that occurred after the Valeant loss has helped the fund become better organized for the future.

The example of Ruane, Cunniff & Goldfarb shows that it’s important to judge an investment fund based on how it’s organized as a business. Evaluators of investment managers should consider the firm’s culture, in term of whether it can handle periods of misfortune with humility, and whether it can reflect on its mistakes in a constructive way.

Evaluating investment managers will always be difficult, but the process of doing so can improve. If people placed greater focus on a firm’s long-term track record, on the various theses behind a firm’s investments and on the firm’s culture, the process of evaluating investment managers would be greatly improved.

Share:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Google+ (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
alphainvestment managerperformancereturns

Post navigation

Previous storySocial Media Companies Endanger Themselves by Acting as Content Filters
Next storyMacron’s Reforms are Critical for France’s Economic Future
Sanjit Deepalam '20
Sanjit Deepalam '20

We recommend

BATS Crash: Problems with High-Frequency Trading?

By DBJ
June 8, 2012November 28, 2015

Philosophy and Strategy in Investing

By Sanjit Deepalam '20
April 2, 2018April 2, 2018

Volatility Compression and the Federal Reserve: Dulling the Market’s Price Discovery Mechanism

By Max Frankel '19
December 6, 2016December 6, 2016

Russian Energy Still Reigns as Tsar on the International Market

By Stanislav Van Genderen
June 10, 2019June 10, 2019

Connect With Us

Connect With Us

Popular

Nigeria House of Reps
Government

Foreign Direct Investment in Nigeria

By DBJ
May 30, 2012September 8, 2016
Khoo Teck Puat Hospital, Singapore. Source: http://www.flickr.com/photos/jui-media/6701517533/
Government

Singapore’s Market-Model Healthcare System

By DBJ
September 1, 2012November 28, 2015
Technology

The Smartwatch – the Next “It” Item?

By DBJ
August 23, 2013November 28, 2015
Consumer

Cutco: Schemers or Success Story?

By Jack Smul '19
August 8, 2016August 8, 2016
Consumer

Fast Food Goes Global

By DBJ
May 12, 2011November 28, 2015
ConsumerInternational

The Korean Wave That Has Engulfed the World

By Eowyn Pak
June 10, 2019June 10, 2019

Random

Government

The Cost of Crisis in Cuba

By DBJ
May 30, 2012November 28, 2015
Markets

The Chinese Boom and Bust

By Emma Ractliffe '17
September 12, 2015November 29, 2015
Government

The Federal Reserve Needs to be Patient

By Joby Bernstein '17
March 16, 2015November 28, 2015
Markets

The Best of Both Worlds: Convertible Bonds

By Charles Fenn
June 10, 2019June 10, 2019
Government

Simple Economics: The US War on Drugs

By Emily Chan '16
August 19, 2014November 28, 2015
Consumer

Boston Beer Co.: Winning in a World of Big Bad Beers

By Holly Jeong '17
November 29, 2015November 29, 2015
10389609_776146039122530_6349977373008057080_n

Dartmouth Business Journal

  • About
  • Contact Us

Quick Navigation

  • Consumer
  • Dartmouth
  • Government
  • International
  • Markets
  • Technology
Copyright 2016 © Dartmouth Business Journal
loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.